Search For
 

 
Discussion Groups: Brandon Chatter


Topic: Looking for opinions: Children walking in this weather
0 Like(s)   


Page1 2Next>
bunny997

1/11/2017 6:52:35 PM
Member since:
Jun 2010
Total posts:43
Looking for opinions: Children walking in this weather

My daughter who is 11 is supposed to go to BU tomorrow morning with her class. They are walking it will take about 15 minutes. My question is would you send your child.

Edited by admin, 2017-01-12 09:38:54. Reason: Title

 
 
  Advertisement
 
bunny997

1/11/2017 6:59:54 PM
Member since:
Jun 2010
Total posts:43
my concern

I am not concerned about safety while walking my concerns are with the temperature.

Giddyup

1/11/2017 7:04:40 PM
Member since:
Apr 2013
Total posts:146
cancelled?

I'm sure the school will cancel it due to the temperature that it's calling for tomorrow morning....-42 I think. They don't have patrols out or recess when it's this cold, I can't imagine them going for a walk.

ronfay

1/11/2017 8:30:43 PM
Member since:
Oct 2006
Total posts:545
Send my kid?

Yes. They can dress for it.

Let'sgetreal

1/11/2017 8:34:20 PM
Member since:
May 2016
Total posts:30
Bsd policy

Is that students have indoor recess at -27 with wind chill. That's a fifteen minute recess. Pretty sure they won't be going.

Brandoncitychick

1/11/2017 9:05:04 PM
Member since:
Sep 2013
Total posts:14
...

My son is also going.  
 
It's Manitoba. It's winter. I have purchased him appropriate outdoor wear. I don't recall ever staying indoors when it was cold outside, I just remember taking a few extra minutes to layer up.

Oryx

1/11/2017 9:21:28 PM
Member since:
Jul 2005
Total posts:5457
Yes

Dress your kid for the weather, seems like a no brainer. Having said that, with the temps they are calling for tomorrow they may cancel it all together.  
To be completely honest, why are you asking for others opinions?

bunny997

1/11/2017 9:25:07 PM
Member since:
Jun 2010
Total posts:43
Oryx

I am asking for others opinions because I am on the fence on if I will let her go and wanted to see what other parents thought. Dressing properly is a no brainer but I know even with proper clothes -43 is still cold.

unbreakable1

1/11/2017 9:25:43 PM
Member since:
Jun 2005
Total posts:1207
yeps

Yes, I will admit its COLD. Overall speaking, we had a tame Winter last year. Having said that from a person who was raised in the North and had to walk 15 minutes to school, I would send the kid if they are dressed for the weather and can walk fast!

Oryx

1/11/2017 9:31:20 PM
Member since:
Jul 2005
Total posts:5457
So

Just wondering then, I have my kids helping out with farm chores in this weather, of course they're dressed for it but chores need to be done each and every day despite the weather. Am I a bad parent for having my kids help out in these temperatures?  
Just needing opinions.

Cheezies

1/11/2017 10:19:03 PM
Member since:
Oct 2010
Total posts:1423
Child

Personally I wouldn't send my child. But that's just me. The wind is supposed to be bad as well as the cold temps. But I was under the understanding that BSD cannot take take the kids out in temps colder than -27. Odds are that it will be canceled or rescheduled. I know any activities my kids had in school in those temps were cancelled.  
It's totally up to you as a parent, in what your confident with.

curlysister

1/11/2017 10:41:07 PM
Member since:
Sep 2009
Total posts:2211
hmmmm

Bunny997 - of course I would bundle my kid up and send him!  
Oryx - of course you are not a bad parent for bundling your kid up to help with chores!

skullsandtattoos

1/11/2017 11:26:52 PM
Member since:
Jul 2016
Total posts:55
way too cold,,,

way too cold to be sending kids out for a leisure walk in this nasty awful weather,,frostbite happens within minutes  
if your thinking its not the right thing to do,,then you already know the answer.

Trixee

1/12/2017 8:20:40 AM
Member since:
Nov 2010
Total posts:2
Was wondering the same

I don't think think this is a no brainer at all. As soon as I got the note I called three of my friends to ask the same question. All three of them did not think it was appropriate for the school to have them walk in this temperature. All three of them also said if they don't send them outside for recess how can they make them walk.

Happy Trails

1/12/2017 8:57:45 AM
Member since:
Feb 2011
Total posts:1003
if

it's too cold to walk, they will either cancel or from my experience bus them last minute. I would /have sent my child when walking field trips were supposed to happen on rotten days & just dressed them for it, but they always either cancel or bus them if it's nasty.

Jellybean

1/12/2017 9:26:02 AM
Member since:
May 2010
Total posts:1237
.........

I don't know why the schools can't plan to have them bussed when doing winter field trips. I know it's an extra cost, but really, come on.  
My oldest has done a field trip where they walked about a 15 minute distance, but it was in the fall.  
The school should always have a back up plan, either cancel, or have a bus plan ready. Even in the fall or spring, there could be heavy rain, which would not be suitable to send kids out to walk in for 15 minutes.

Linnie

1/12/2017 10:06:29 AM
Member since:
Apr 2009
Total posts:182
Would you walk?

If you, as a parent, are willing to walk 15 minutes each way when it's this cold then send your child.  
Maybe calling the school to find our if they will walk regardless of weather is a good idea.

hisluvmonkey

1/12/2017 12:22:36 PM
Member since:
Oct 2009
Total posts:1155
Did they go?

Just interested to see what the outcome of this was.

bunny997

1/12/2017 3:57:58 PM
Member since:
Jun 2010
Total posts:43
hisluvmonkey

Thanks for asking, they did go but had parent volunteers drive the kids as it was too cold to walk.

sprinter

1/12/2017 9:18:02 PM
Member since:
Oct 2011
Total posts:292
Temps

Is it just me or do others think that these kids now a days are pampered far too much.  
Our kids would bundle up and play outside, even in -30 weather, keep moving with layered clothing and you stay warm.  
The kids in town couldn't wait for hockey game cancellations and head to the rink for 3-4 hour scrimmages with all ages involved.  
I used to walk to the country school, 2 miles, others walked over a mile.  
Now it seems the kids have to look "cool" and wear next to nothing.  
Running shoes, short jackets, no parka, and hands in pockets of jeans.  
Am i wrong for thinking that a lot of parents are not parenting, but just letting the child do what ever

Oryx

1/12/2017 9:28:31 PM
Member since:
Jul 2005
Total posts:5457
Sprinter...

my thoughts exactly. I don't even know why a parent would have to ask the opinions of other parents in regard to an issue such as this. Either your kid can do it or they can't. Quit babying your kid. You know them best.  
I am glad to know that my kids can withstand these temperatures because they are dressed appropriately and they know that things have to get done regardless of the weather.

Jellybean

1/12/2017 9:49:55 PM
Member since:
May 2010
Total posts:1237
.......

What's wrong with asking opinions? This is more of a matter of safety, not whether you are coddling your children too much. My kids are all dressed properly for the weather, and they love being outside, but the reality is that these temperatures can get dangerous quickly. Kids aren't always responsible enough when young to make sure they get all bundled and covered up properly on their own.  
Don't forget either that some people cannot afford winter wear that can be of proper protection in extreme temperatures. If you can only afford a snow suit from Walmart, I'm sorry, but those things would not keep a child warm enough for a long period of time at -40. My kids have had these types of snow suits, and I wouldn't buy them again, but some people have no choice.  
Schools have minimum temperature regulations in place for safety, not just for fun.

Oryx

1/12/2017 9:55:43 PM
Member since:
Jul 2005
Total posts:5457
Jellybean

You're totally right!

GordonSchwindt

1/13/2017 6:11:49 AM
Member since:
Jun 2009
Total posts:408
society needs to dress for winter

We are becoming a community of wimps. Yes it is cold. Use your head and dress. Yesterday I repaired a snow blower out doors. I took my gloves off a couple of times. Actually was pleasantly surprised how comfortable I was doing so. It is cold but I wore a heavy vest under insulated coveralls. I had felt pack boots and a fur hat. Unfortunately society dresses for style. I taught school for years. Many students and parents complained of the cold but arrived without head coverings. Jeans and tennis shoes not designed for walking outside in winter. I used to say buses have fire drills. They should have cold weather breakdown drills. Stop bus and have students walk a couple of blocks Even in -10 weather many are inadequately dressed. That said. I am eagerly waiting for spring.

Knucklehead

1/13/2017 7:34:29 AM
Member since:
Jun 2014
Total posts:233
Sprinter

I totally agree. Kids these days are way to pampered. There's no reason a 15 minute walk should cause so much worry if the child is dressed appropriately, boots, skipants, jacket, mitts scarves, etc. If you pamper them now how are they gonna learn to deal with it when they're old enough to have jobs that may require to be outside? It's almost sickening the way kids are pampered these days.

Adam

1/13/2017 8:31:41 AM
Member since:
Mar 2005
Total posts:15109
Exposed skin

From Environment Canada's extreme cold warning that's currently in place and has been for much of the past few days, "Frostbite on exposed skin is possible within 10 minutes in these conditions"  
http://weather.gc.ca/warnings/report_e.html?mb7

And Government of Manitoba's release relating to practicing cold weather safety where they note some of the more at-risk groups and share a lot of good information on how to keep safe during stretches of weather like the one we're going through. Among the tips, "reschedule outdoor activities and/or limit time outdoors if severe weather is forecast". On the bright side, single-digit highs by the end of the weekend to the point where by Tuesday the high is zero!
http://news.gov.mb.ca/news/index.html?archive=&item=40350

Doug

1/13/2017 9:32:30 AM
Member since:
Mar 2005
Total posts:6814
careful

yep.I also expect those kids would dress for the weather. Cripes@  11 I delivered the newspaper after school in colder. Layers layers. good boots and toques. Never ever too cold If dressed for it.

snowman5

1/13/2017 10:31:33 AM
Member since:
Nov 2009
Total posts:865
Some opinions will be conflicting...

There will always be extreme opposites at either end of the spectrum of opinions. I for one, believes that ten or twenty minutes for a well dressed kid while moving about, builds character and does not harm. Letting my kids (youngest in grade three and oldest in High school) walk a block or two to school is good for them, while other parents will warm up their cars drive the same distance as ours have to do and stop on the crosswalk to drop-off/pick-up their 'little un-bundled of joy'. It irritates me, but it also does cracks me up. Minus forty these last few days and for some, neither parent or kid got a brain between them. It only proves my theory that stupidity must be genetic. Yesterday, I saw teens in their shorts and a sweat shirt getting picked up, shorts! What a proud moment it must be for a parent when picking up your athletic offspring after practice wearing the same outfit they wore in September. Yeah, they were hot in the gym, but it must feel really good to hop into the vehicle with all those windows still frosted on the inside. *sarcasm* Or another proud moment when they drop off the little angel dressed in jacket that ends halfway down their waist, no mitts or hat but in fuzzy slippers and leggings. So, I guess we can all get to see the little @$$ that's about to freeze off. LOL I know as a parent we have to pick our battles with out older kids, but seriously... This would shame me if I were seen with or known that was my kid getting in or out of the car dressed like that. ...As for the parents of the younger kids... I suppose the 'bubble wrap' does keep them warm and that makes you some kind of "super parent" (super paranoid, that is), but get over yourself. Want to be a better parent? It starts with not making lame excuses and by teaching the kid the basic skills and setting the example of dressing warm, thinking to adapt and anticipate their surroundings. Not letting them rely on Mom & Dad to provide all the solutions or worse... just having one solution. It's astonishing how these younger generations come out totally unprepared during the Canadian winter. It reminds me of the story of the young mother who wrecked her car and froze her feet while trying to keep her kid warm through the night. She was deemed a hero, but I found her incredibly stupid. Sweats, a pull-over, flip-flops, cell phone and a warm car for a twenty minute drive between towns on a winters night. Everything's good because she has her phone, right? ...Well, it wasn't. Both her and the kid was thrown from the vehicle (never understood how, if they should've been secured with belts), phone gone, cold and injured. The accident itself may have been unavoidable, but the outcome should have been ...if she were more prepared. We assure ourselves with false security like warm cars, phones and door to door trips ...but it's sooo wrong to be thinking that way. And to top it off! Some of us are conditioning their kids to think the same way by either depending on the fact that nothing can go wrong or the exact opposite. By totally wimping out and not adapting to changes. My wife had to work minus a few people these past days because co-workers felt it too cold and "drifty" to drive in from the Shilo area. Really? They chose to live there. They should have a plan for days like these. Get up earlier, pack a shovel & essentials, dress accordingly, suck it up and get your @$$ to work. And that's the same for kids going to school. Prepare them, don't pamper them. Walk with them if you're concerned. I did that. Especially if there were no crossing guards. This is such easy stuff, why must it be made so complicated when the weather gets harsh. Oh, that's right! We aren't prepared for it. So who's fault is that?  
 
Just my opinion, I could be wrong. ...but warm.

withallduerespect

1/13/2017 4:02:20 PM
Member since:
Jul 2013
Total posts:126
it's an age thing

I remember my grandma and my parents giving me crap for only wearing runners in the winter, and not having a hat, but I shrugged it off and ignored them, then froze my toes after we hit the ditch. Now I find myself having the same conversations with my kids who roll their eyes and ignore me for the most part.  
 
Then my son's buddy hit the ditch a few days ago and they came to get me to help pull them out. Before we went I was layering up while they stood there watching me impatiently. I offered them better boots, mitts, toques, etc but they didn't see the need. OK I said. 15 minutes out there trying to get the tow rope on and they were absolutely frozen stiff. Lesson learned, sort of.

Trevor B

1/13/2017 4:20:17 PM
Member since:
Apr 2005
Total posts:7837
When I lived

in Douglas, whenever the windchill got to that magical value the busses didn't run. But the school was open. And being a town kid, I had to bundle up and still walk to school. Even when it was -40 or worse. The same with blizzard conditions. I very, very rarely had a ride to school. And depending on where the our babysitter was located in town, it was a long walk. And that i:ncluded crossing railway tracks.

 
Page1 2Next>


  Get E-mail/text alerts for this discussion    
Bookmark and Share
This thread has gone more than 90 days without a reply and has been closed as a result. Please feel free to start a new topic should you feel it is warranted.

   

 

Current Discussions

 
 
 

Classified Ads

 
 

Blogs

 
 

Local Business Directory

 
 
Blue Lion Photogrpahy
You will receive art-like images and albums which have a scenic quality, are emotionally charged and have a natural look with an artistic impression. We also incorporate some aspects of wedding photojournalism into your final albums. It is a refreshing new approach to wedding photography. These photographs will have an unposed and spontaneous feel. It takes a instinctive creativity to be able to combine portraiture and storytelling photography in an album and keep everything natural. More..
Piano Technician
Chris Keller, Piano Technician. 27 Years of Experience. Free Estimates. Cell: 574-6499 More..
Business for Sale
Pelican Lake Campgrounds for sale. 1. Pelican Shores 2. Strathcona Park Store & Campground 100% occupancy. Call Fay for details 204.724.4456. More..