Joined: Sep 2007
Posts: 1537
Whatever the situation, it sounds as though you have to be blunt with her and deal with the fallout whatever it might be. Being concerned about not hurting feelings and being gentle in your answer will not solve this sort of problem.
I see that there are possibly two situations that you are encountering...and maybe both. It is too hard to tell which it is with such a little information. Here are my solutions to both. They work well.
1. If the only problem is that this woman is opinionated, tell her that her that as much as you respect that she has opinions, that constant sharing of those opinions is not appreciated. You can think for yourself. Tell her if you want to get her advice, you will certainly ask. She will be offended initially and maybe for a while, but set that boundary and stick to it.
2. If it is a matter of a controlling sister in law, this is what I have done with a similar type of person. It will be hard. You will most likely offend her, but that is okay. She is not respecting you. You need to set boundaries with a controlling person like this. If you do this, you will feel like the bad one for a while, but you are not bad for sticking up for yourself. I found doing the following extremely freeing. It was totally worth it and puts you in control in that situation.
First of all, always be on guard.
Secondly, just say NO. All the time, EVERY time. Give no reasons why. That only gives an invitation for her to manipulate you. It might sound extreme, and yes, it is, but it will set firm boundaries. I encountered a "guilt trip" type of response from the person when I said no, and she also used someone else to be her mouthpiece and tried to "guilt trip" through them too. I still said NO. It was hard.
If you can get your husband on board, get him to do the same with her. Often a controller or manipulator will try to go through him too...or through someone else that might hold sway over you.
The key is to be consistent. It will get worse before it gets better. Hang in there. When she finally backs off after quite some time (you will know the time), be willing to consider her thoughts, but be just as ready to reinstate "NO" if the situation requires.