If you are overwhelmed and don't know where to start, a DIY website solution is a bad place to start. Folks quite often look at a $1500 website budget at face value but don't consider a website will stay contemporary for about 3 - 4 years if you start with a good design.
It's not just the technical aspects of building your site you have to worry about - does the person you are working with understand your business if you only communicate by email? Once they understand your business they are able to set your site up with appropriate calls to action and lead capture features and consult you on direction and type of content will and will not be ideal for your business site.
If you are investing money into your site it should be working for you and generate clients - even $400 is a waste of money if it doesn't turn up a lead. But what if a $1500 site provides $5000 in leads in a year? You can DIY a website and you can DIY dry walling from YouTube (been there

but you can always tell...
That being said - post your website link if you've done it yourself or went overseas! Very curious!