Joined: May 2016
Posts: 103
Strange Logic
7/26/2018 at 1:18 PM
This logic presupposes that the only thing that makes a professional athlete or a professional musician wealthy are a few extra hours a week practicing during recess.
To be clear the people who make it to the NBA, NHL, NFL etc, they're rich. But they're not just a little talented. They're not just "practicing at recess" talented. They're extremely physically gifted, they grow up in the right locations, are put in the right situations, with the right coaches and teammates, work their butts off doing 2-a-days their entire lives and if they're REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY lucky, then they might make it pro.
Even then, there is a HUGE difference between making it pro, and becoming wealthy. How many players get drafted to the NHL every year and never play? Or play a handful of games and then go back to the minors? Even if you DO make it pro, you're competing against literally the best in the world.
This is not a question of recess. It's a question of amazing genetics, amazing talent, amazing work ethic, amazing support, and a whole lot of luck.
Music is even MORE luck. Because it's often not even necessarily about talent. Dont get me wrong there are a lot of really really talented musicians out there that make a lot of money. But unlike sports, wealth is not necessarily tied to talent.
Example: Bieber makes a lot more money than say...John Mayer. He is objectively much less talented than Mayer.
Or Malmsteen is a much better guitarist than say Tom Delonge formerly of Blink 182. Tom makes WAY more money.
But even moreso, talent alone means nothing in music. There are a lot of incredibly incredibly talented musicians working at Dennys. While there are a lot of terrible mumble rappers and pop-sensations who have nothing more than good looks and a decent voice making millions.
This isn't about recess. It's about luck. Again, i'm not saying very talented people dont get rich making music, I'm just saying that talent is not the defining factor. In most cases it's marketability.