Are all of your efforts focused online? Get out and meet people! You indicated that you have a job and a degree. Do your coworkers go out after work on a Friday? Do you have any hobbies that involve groups of people (co-ed sports, board games, book clubs, etc)?
My girlfriend came into my life when I wasn't even looking! I had been separated just shy of a year, gone through the grieving of that relationship, and had started getting on with my life: a new relationship wasn't something I was even thinking of looking for. Keeping busy with sports and going out for coffee with co-workers was my way of being social.
One of my co-workers had a friend who she would often invite for coffee with our group. We became friends and one day I realized I liked her...really liked her!

Being shy to the point of having anxiety I worked up the nerve to tell her how I felt! Almost five years later we're still together! I still think she's out of my league and pinch myself everyday to see that I'm not dreaming!
Anyway, my point is that I believe people come into our life and sometimes we need to take a chance and just go for it! I wasn't looking for love or in the dating scene! We started out as casual acquaintances! I'm sure you have friends who can introduce you to women who might be a match. And if it's not romantic, well, maybe you just make a new friend! Friends are great to have!
Relax and don't put so much pressure on yourself! Good luck! I hope you find someone as amazing as I did!